7 Essential Strategies to Overcome the Female Likability Liability & Bias

Most senior leaders understand that relationships form the foundation of effective leadership. Authenticity naturally fosters genuine likability, which builds trust and connection. Yet, for many women in leadership, the expectation to be likable often creates tension—balancing authenticity with the scrutiny and biases they face. This dynamic can turn likability into a double-edged sword, offering both opportunities and challenges.

We’re told to be approachable but assertive, kind but not weak, strong but not intimidating. The line we’re expected to walk is razor-thin. While likability can open doors, it can also create invisible barriers, preventing women from fully stepping into their potential. The key is recognizing when likability serves us—and when it holds us back.

This challenge manifests in two ways: the Likability Bias imposed by others, rooted in societal expectations, and the Likability Liability we internalize, creating self-imposed limits. Understanding and addressing both is essential for authentic and impactful leadership.

Case Study: Recognizing Likability Bias in Action

In a recent search for a start-up CEO, we interviewed two highly qualified candidates: one man and one woman. Both brought strong skills and seemed equally viable for the role. However, feedback from the HR leader’s reference checks revealed clear bias:

The Male Candidate: With an operational background, he was described as a “hard charger” who pushed through conflict to achieve results. His assertiveness was framed as a strength, even though it was clear that he wasn’t focused on making friends.
The Female Candidate: With expertise in strategy, vision, and navigating uncertainty, her skills aligned more closely with the demands of a start-up CEO. Yet, feedback from former colleagues noted she sometimes had “fights” with peers—a comment the HR leader considered a significant concern and potential disqualifier.

This inconsistency stood out to me. In her interview, the female candidate framed these conflicts as examples of overcoming resistance and driving meaningful change—hallmarks of effective leadership. Yet, the same assertiveness that was celebrated in the male candidate was criticized in the woman, highlighting a clear likability bias.

When I pointed this out, it became evident the HR leader hadn’t recognized the double standard. This case underscores the research that shows that women are frequently penalized for behaviors that are deemed acceptable—or even celebrated—in men. This bias can manifest as feedback like: “You’re too aggressive,” “Too pushy,” or “You need to soften your approach.”

In the Harvard Business Review article “For Women Leaders, Likability and Success Hardly Go Hand-in-Hand, Marianne Cooper writes:¹

“... high-achieving women experience social backlash because their very success – and specifically the behaviors that created that success – violates our expectations about how women are supposed to behave. Women are expected to be nice, warm, friendly, and nurturing. Thus, if a woman acts assertively or competitively, if she pushes her team to perform, if she exhibits decisive and forceful leadership, she is deviating from the social script that dictates how she “should” behave.”

These biases not only reinforce inequities but also hinder women from fully stepping into their leadership potential. Recognizing and addressing these double standards is critical to creating a fairer and more inclusive leadership culture.

Turning Inward: Unmasking Our Own Likability Liability

A deeper and more insidious challenge lies in the self-limiting beliefs created by our own “likability liability.” I often observe this when coaching executive women leaders— likability can subtly be masked as the pursuit of approval. When approval becomes an unconscious priority, it can narrow our thinking and undermine our leadership potential.

Likability can hinder leadership when it causes us to:

Avoid tough conversations to preserve harmony.
Feel pressured to prioritize being liked over staying aligned with our values.
Worry about appearing “too pushy” when advocating for ourselves or our teams.

But here’s the truth: leadership isn’t about being liked by everyone. It’s about driving meaningful impact while staying true to your values and purpose. Expanding leadership potential means shifting from a mindset of likability to one of influence. Often, the first step is simply calling out and unmasking these hidden biases within ourselves. Recognizing them is the key to unlocking greater leadership authenticity and effectiveness.

Recognizing when likability limits your leadership is essential. Ask yourself:

Is likability holding me back from making tough decisions?
Am I avoiding risks or necessary conversations to maintain approval?
Have I aligned my leadership with my purpose, or am I conforming to others’ expectations?

These are the moments to pause, reflect, and recalibrate. Leadership isn’t about being universally liked—it’s about being respected and impactful. Likability is the door to approval, but approval-seeking is a trap that pulls us away from our true potential.

Reframing Likability: The Seven Essential Strategies

At its best, likability builds trust, fosters alignment, and creates meaningful professional relationships. Reflect on this: at some point in your career, someone likely took a chance on you because they believed in your abilities—and, to some degree, found you likable. But what if we shifted the focus? Instead of striving for likability, what if we reframed it as aligning with our authentic selves, building meaningful connections, and cultivating inner strength?

By forging genuine connections, aligning with organizational goals, and enhancing your influence, you can break free from the forces that often hold us in the status quo.

Here are seven strategies to transform likability into a leadership strength rooted in authenticity and impact:

Align with Organizational Goals
Root your decisions and actions in your organization’s mission and values. When your leadership aligns with shared goals, you’re less likely to feel trapped by the need to be universally liked.
Leverage Relationships
Understand what motivates your team and stakeholders. Frame difficult conversations around shared objectives or outcomes to foster alignment, even when the message is tough.
Be Transparent
When possible, share the “why” behind your decisions. Transparency builds respect, even if the message isn’t what others want to hear.
Deliver Your Message Effectively
It’s not just what you say but how you say it. Empathy and clarity are key. Tailor your delivery to ensure your stakeholders hear and understand your message. It’s ok if they don’t like your message, and they can still appreciate that it was delivered thoughtfully.
Unmask Your Own Likability Liability
Consider whether likability is shaping your decisions, preventing tough conversations, or keeping you from reaching your full potential. Simply recognizing this influence is often enough to shift your perspective and break free from its constraints.
Detach from Reactions
Let go of trying to control how others perceive you. If your actions align with your values and purpose, their opinion is not the ultimate measure of your effectiveness. What’s better: to be true to your personal values or conform to others?

For Allies: Address Likability Bias in Action
Addressing likability bias also requires intentional effort from allies who want to create more equitable and inclusive leadership environments. By actively addressing likability bias, allies can help dismantle systemic barriers and create opportunities for women leaders to thrive authentically.

‍

Here are key ways allies can support women leaders:

Recognize and Challenge Double Standards
- Pay attention to feedback that penalizes assertive or decisive women leaders. Ask if similar behaviors would be criticized in men.
Amplify Women’s Contributions
- Ensure women’s ideas and voices are acknowledged and credited in group settings. Amplifying contributions combat the perception that assertiveness is unlikable.
Provide Constructive Feedback
- Frame feedback in ways that focus on outcomes and behaviors without imposing gendered expectations. Avoid terms like “too aggressive” or “not soft enough.”
Support Equitable Decision-Making
- Encourage discussions about potential bias in hiring, promotions, and evaluations. Share examples, like discrepancies in how likability is perceived, to foster awareness and accountability.
Model and Encourage Authenticity
- Create spaces where authenticity is celebrated, showing that likability and strong leadership are not mutually exclusive.

Summary: Moving Forward with Authenticity, Purpose, & Allies

Likability isn’t inherently negative, but it’s not the ultimate goal. True leadership stems from leading with clarity of purpose and embracing your authentic self. By unmasking likability’s hidden barriers and building meaningful relationships, you can drive positive change, overcome limitations, and lead with greater impact.

In addition, allies play a vital role in dismantling likability bias. They challenge double standards, amplify women’s contributions, and provide unbiased, constructive feedback. Allies who actively address these biases help create environments where authenticity and leadership are valued, fostering equitable opportunities for all.

I’d love to hear from you:

How has likability or seeking “approval” shaped your leadership journey or limited your potential?
What strategies have helped you navigate likability bias?
How have allies supported your growth, and what can you ask of them to magnify your potential?
Who might you approach as an ally with, “Hey, I could use your help…”? How could fostering this relationship create meaningful change for you and amplify equity across our business communities?
Pay it forward: Talk with young girls and boys through informed conversations about gender stereotypes that inhibit men and women from realizing their full potential.

Let’s continue this conversation and support one another in leading with purpose and authenticity.

#ExecutiveCoaching #Leadership #Likability #WomenInLeadership #Authenticity #Alignment

Cooper, Marianne. "For Women Leaders, Likability and Success Hardly Go Hand-in-Hand." Harvard Business Review, 30 Apr. 2013.

Let's Stay Connected